Online ordering powered by Seamless
57 WEST 48TH ST. (48th St. between 5th Ave. & 6th Ave.)(212) 262-6200
Minimum order of $30.00 is required for delivery
Delivery estimate is 20 - 35 min (more info)
Seamless allows you to enjoy convenient online ordering from the best local restaurants. If you're ordering for the first time, start your order by entering your address to the right. Return users log in here.
Print this menu
Consuming raw or undercooked meat, poultry or shellfish may increase your risk of food-borne illness.
From your first meal at AJ Maxwell’s you’ll notice something different…and something comfortingly familiar. The difference is the fresh interpretation of steakhouse favorites, the emphasis on restaurant basics—great food and professional service—and the level of attention they give every customer, whether it is a first-time visitor or a three-times-a-week regular.
Read more
When it comes to comfort, AJ Maxwell’s has put together a sophisticated staff attuned to the nuances of the customers—able to give attention when needed, privacy when warranted, to promote a festive mood at celebrations and appropriate discretion at business meetings. They pride themselves on the little things that mean so much, because at AJ Maxwell’s, it’s not just about the food, it’s about the whole dining experience. AJ Maxwell’s is glad to be able to bring their food to your table at home or your desk at the office with SeamlessWeb. Hopefully you will enjoy eating their food as much as they enjoy preparing it for you!
Hide
Calamari Fritto
Classic Caesar Salad
Filet Mignon
AJ Maxwell’s Cheeseburger
Cheese and Steak Quesadilla
Horseradish-Crusted Salmon
I ordered simple steak sandwich with greek salad. Time estimated for delivery was 50-5 minutes. It took more than 80 minutes to arrive and was not only cold, but greasy and non-appetizing. I called Seemless support and they had to contact restaurant to chase down order. The steak itself was very tasty - but that was it. I didn't finish the meal. The order was also incorrect - I had ordered mustard, but none was included. Won't be back to this place (either by Seemless or in person anytime soon).
Posted a month ago by Dennis V.
Service was way too slow, the steak was cooked unevenly (half well-done, half medium-rare) and would have been poor quality even it was cooked properly, poor seasoning on the food, the potatoes au gratin came in a block of onion and had a somewhat rubbery texture, and the cheesecake was average at best. The food is definitely not worth the price-- easily the worst steak I have ever had in New York
Posted 2 months ago by Bryan P.
Awful 90 minutes later... we are still waiting. When we called... they were RUDE. Don't order from this place!
Posted 3 months ago by Eric S.
we ordered menu (delivery time is 6:30pm). but we got the meny at 4:50pm.
Posted 7 months ago by Chris P.
Have ordered the cheeseburger a few times. It's a big burger with a huge side of fries and onion rings. They must use the trimmings of their steaks because the meat oozes quality, very well marbled. However, this can also lead to a mushy burger because of the fat content. Also on several occasions the burger came well-done even though I ordered medium rare - It seemed as if someone just threw the burger into the fryer. Also it is quite pricey for a burger that is hit or miss, surprisingly so considering it is a steakhouse, and the cooks cannot even cook meat correctly?
Posted 8 months ago by Philip L.
Was very happy with the delivery. Food was hot and burger was very juicy. I ordered med-well and it came perfect. Great food.
Posted 9 months ago by Christina C.
considering I just ordered $120 worth of food, I would expect some service. Its been 80 minutes, (estimated delivery says 35-50 minutes). I called several times, and the guy that answered kept trying to get off the phone with me, and didn't apologize once.
Posted 11 months ago by Roger L.
The food is usually good (although once in a while it seems the prep was rushed), but get ready to add at least 60 minutes to the delivery time. If you're really hungry, order from somewhere else. It's been 75 minutes, I'm still waiting, and all the restaurant can say is that they are sorry.
Posted a year ago by Irina V.
Our First order was Amazing!!! Our second order was just as GREAT as the first order. This could be simply one the BEST steakhouse I have frequented. By far it is the BEST steakhouse I have ordered from and will definitely order again SOON :)
Posted a year ago by Jerry C.
Food nice but cold with no utensils
Posted a year ago by Peter C.
I was extremely surprised that the $23 spinach salad comes with 3 grilled shrimp served over a few wilted leaves of spinach and a total of 2 halved cherry tomatoes. I've been ordering on seamless for over 4 years and have never once had occasion to write a bad review until now.
Posted a year ago by Julia S.
It's expensive but well worth it. Seriously. Get it if you can. Everything is absolutely delicious, from their cheeseburgers (which includes a full side of onion rings and fries) and their prix fixe dinner (mine included lobster bisque (soup of the day - it was OK), an amazing, perfectly done filet mignon with well made mashed potatoes with microchive garnish, and a delicious small cheesecake). I was also impressed that all their steaks come with a real metal knife! Very classy! Makes it way better than relying on a cheap plastic knife that can't do a good steak justice. Long story short: why haven't you already placed your order here yet?
Posted a year ago by Clarinda L.
Fine meat.
Posted 2 years ago by Daniel P.
Everything we were looking for...a little pricey but delicious nonetheless!!!
Posted 3 years ago by Joanne A.
This was, by far, the best delivery we've gotten through Seamless Web. Delivery was prompt. Packaging was great. The food was absolutely delicious. Yes, it's more expensive than most other places on this site, but the portions are huge! I ordered Surf & Turf, and the "petit" filet was bigger than most restaurants sell as a full version. Definitely will order again.
Posted 3 years ago by Nonna S.
Only select user reviews are published on Seamless. All user-submitted ratings contribute to AJ Maxwell's's overall Seamless rating, but we manually screen all reviews and only publish those that are relevant and helpful. Tips for getting your review published »
Above content provided by restaurant.
Order online from AJ Maxwell's by entering your address below. Online ordering powered by Seamless.com.
Return users log in here.
Click a menu item to add it to your order.
Back to top